Saturday, 22 April 2023

MANCHESTER CITY-"THE INVINCIBLES"??

Manchester City put aside Sheffield United this evening in the FA Cup Semi-Final, 3-0. Bit of a mismatch but the question is; Is Manchester City the best club ever? Here are the City's results against The Blades from City's formation in March 1893:

Sheffield United v Manchester City

Games won:38
Games drawn:34
Games lost:54
DateMatchResultScoreCompetition
04 Mar 1893Ardwick v Sheffield UnitedW2-3League Division Two
25 Mar 1893Sheffield United v ArdwickW2-1League Division Two
07 Oct 1899Sheffield United v Manchester CityW3-0League Division One
25 Dec 1899Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW1-2League Division One
22 Dec 1900Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
26 Dec 1900Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
23 Nov 1901Sheffield United v Manchester CityW5-0League Division One
22 Mar 1902Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL4-0League Division One
03 Oct 1903Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-1League Division One
28 Dec 1903Sheffield United v Manchester CityW5-3League Division One
24 Sep 1904Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD1-1League Division One
21 Jan 1905Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-3League Division One
04 Nov 1905Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-3League Division One
13 Jan 1906Sheffield United v Manchester CityW4-1FA Cup
10 Mar 1906Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW1-2League Division One
17 Nov 1906Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-2League Division One
23 Mar 1907Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-4League Division One
11 Mar 1908Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-2League Division One
28 Mar 1908Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-2League Division One
12 Dec 1908Sheffield United v Manchester CityW4-0League Division One
17 Apr 1909Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW1-3League Division One
08 Oct 1910Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-4League Division One
11 Feb 1911Sheffield United v Manchester CityD2-2League Division One
30 Sep 1911Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0League Division One
26 Feb 1912Sheffield United v Manchester CityW6-2League Division One
05 Oct 1912Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
08 Feb 1913Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-0League Division One
13 Sep 1913Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-3League Division One
03 Jan 1914Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
07 Mar 1914Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0FA Cup
12 Mar 1914Sheffield United v Manchester CityD0-0FA Cup
16 Mar 1914Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-1FA Cup
07 Nov 1914Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0League Division One
29 Mar 1915Sheffield United v Manchester CityD0-0League Division One
30 Aug 1919Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD3-3League Division One
06 Sep 1919Sheffield United v Manchester CityW3-1League Division One
09 Apr 1921Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
16 Apr 1921Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
01 Apr 1922Sheffield United v Manchester CityW1-0League Division One
08 Apr 1922Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD2-2League Division One
26 Aug 1922Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-0League Division One
02 Sep 1922Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD3-3League Division One
25 Aug 1923Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
01 Sep 1923Sheffield United v Manchester CityW3-0League Division One
27 Sep 1924Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-5League Division One
23 Feb 1925Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
26 Oct 1925Sheffield United v Manchester CityW8-3League Division One
04 Nov 1925Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW2-4League Division One
01 Dec 1928Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-3League Division One
13 Apr 1929Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-1League Division One
23 Nov 1929Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-2League Division One
29 Mar 1930Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
20 Sep 1930Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-4League Division One
28 Jan 1931Sheffield United v Manchester CityD2-2League Division One
03 Oct 1931Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD1-1League Division One
15 Feb 1932Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-1League Division One
05 Nov 1932Sheffield United v Manchester CityL2-5League Division One
22 Mar 1933Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL1-0League Division One
28 Oct 1933Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
10 Mar 1934Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL4-1League Division One
22 Oct 1938Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-2League Division Two
21 Jan 1939Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-0FA Cup
25 Feb 1939Sheffield United v Manchester CityW1-0League Division Two
13 Dec 1947Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL4-3League Division One
01 May 1948Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-1League Division One
09 Oct 1948Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-2League Division One
05 Mar 1949Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL1-0League Division One
09 Dec 1950Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL5-3League Division Two
28 Apr 1951Sheffield United v Manchester CityD0-0League Division Two
25 Dec 1953Sheffield United v Manchester CityD2-2League Division One
26 Dec 1953Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
25 Aug 1954Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL5-2League Division One
30 Aug 1954Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-2League Division One
08 Oct 1955Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
11 Apr 1956Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-1League Division One
11 Nov 1961Sheffield United v Manchester CityW3-1League Division One
31 Mar 1962Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD1-1League Division One
03 Apr 1963Sheffield United v Manchester CityW3-1League Division One
24 Apr 1963Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW1-3League Division One
01 Apr 1967Sheffield United v Manchester CityW1-0League Division One
06 May 1967Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD1-1League Division One
16 Sep 1967Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL5-2League Division One
20 Jan 1968Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-3League Division One
23 Oct 1971Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-1League Division One
12 Feb 1972Sheffield United v Manchester CityD3-3League Division One
09 Dec 1972Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
14 Apr 1973Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-1League Division One
20 Oct 1973Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-2League Division One
16 Mar 1974Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW0-1League Division One
06 Aug 1974Sheffield United v Manchester CityW4-2Texaco Cup
07 Dec 1974Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-2League Division One
11 Jan 1975Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
09 Aug 1975Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-1Anglo-Scottish Cup
01 Nov 1975Sheffield United v Manchester CityD2-2League Division One
06 Mar 1976Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL4-0League Division One
17 Nov 1984Sheffield United v Manchester CityD0-0League Division Two
20 Apr 1985Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-0League Division Two
22 Oct 1985Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-2Full Members Cup
10 Oct 1987Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedW2-3League Division Two
08 Mar 1988Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-2League Division Two
02 Nov 1988Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL4-2League Cup
08 Sep 1990Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division One
19 Jan 1991Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-0League Division One
22 Jan 1991Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-2Zenith Data Systems Cup
26 Oct 1991Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL3-2League Division One
08 Feb 1992Sheffield United v Manchester CityW4-2League Division One
26 Dec 1992Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-0Premier League
09 Apr 1993Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1Premier League
25 Sep 1993Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-1Premier League
19 Mar 1994Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0Premier League
28 Sep 1996Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-0League Division 1
29 Jan 1997Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0League Division 1
15 Nov 1997Sheffield United v Manchester CityD1-1League Division 1
21 Mar 1998Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0League Division 1
21 Aug 1999Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL6-0League Division 1
22 Jan 2000Sheffield United v Manchester CityW1-0League Division 1
16 Oct 2001Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0League Division 1
01 Jan 2002Sheffield United v Manchester CityL1-3League Division 1
14 Oct 2006Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedD0-0Premier League
26 Dec 2006Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-1Premier League
27 Jan 2008Sheffield United v Manchester CityW2-1FA Cup
29 Dec 2019Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL2-0Premier League
21 Jan 2020Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-1Premier League
31 Oct 2020Sheffield United v Manchester CityL0-1Premier League
30 Jan 2021Manchester City v Sheffield UnitedL1-0Premier League
22 Apr 2023Manchester City v Sheffield United

Note previous FA Cup ties.

Friday, 21 April 2023

THE LIVERPOOL "FOOTBALL ECHO"


The Liverpool Football Echo, on April 21st 1906, reported that the English Cup Final had been held at The Crystal Palace, with an immense crowd of 75,609, packing the stadium to witness Everton play Newcastle United, when, at last, the cup went to the city of Liverpool.

The report was sent by "Spire Wire" and the growing popularity of football was finally recognised, with no radio, "Sports' Report" was available at the time, but only as newspaper reports.

It might have been a wait until Sunday morning or even Monday, when the "Athletic News" appeared to report the Saturday results. Liverpool was the first city to launch the "Football Echo" as early as 1901. The city's two clubs, Liverpool and Everton, had both won the League Championship (First and top division in those days) with 40,000 or more watching the two Merseyside clubs.

The inside pages of news of the paper were printed already and when the results came out, they were included in the outside pages, at the last minute. Scores were telegraphed to the Echo's office and the race began to get the paper onto the street corners as quickly as possible.

In 1906, Liverpool became the first city to produce both the FA Cup winner and First Division League title holder in the same season. Liverpool won the League title from Preston and Everton, having beaten Liverpool at Aston Villa  in the semi-final of the Cup, went on to win the FA Cup.

Everton's victory over Newcastle in the final served as a perfect example of how reports were wired back to the "office". The type set for the match was done in preparation and the report of the game written minute by minute to hasten the publication. Messengers wired the minute report to the "Echo's Office" and compositors would begin the typeset the one setence text on to the page so that once the final whistle was blown, printing could begin.


Details of the match would often get lost deep in the text, for example, the winning goal scored by Sandy Young, did not occur until near the end of the report at 4.55pm:
IT READ...."At last a goal, Sandy Young the hero. Fireworks and minature (sic) earthquakes in galore-shades of San Francisco (actually this disaster happened the week before).  Not the greatest way of a minute by minute sporting event but at the time it served the purpose of getting the news and all the results on to the streets as quickly as possible.
Two of Lancashire's most celebrated  sportsmen helped Everton win the FA Cup for the first time. They were Jack Sharp and Harry Makepeace (below). They had both played full international games for England at football and cricket. (apparently there have only been 12 players to achieve this accolade).
FA Cup finals 1906 II | Everton
Sharp was a right winger and Makepeace, a half back. 
Between them, for Lancashire CCC, they had scored nearly 80 hundreds!
Makepeace had won an FA Cup winner's medal, a League Championhsip medal (1915), a cricket Championship medal (actually four!) and played for England at both football and cricket.

Sharp provided the cross from which Young scored the winning goal, fifteen minutes from the end.
The Magpies lost the final at Crystal Palace for the second year running, having been beaten by Aston Villa 2-0 in 1905; 101,117 watched this earlier disappointment.
AND
On 21st April 1990, player-manager Ian Bowyer and his son Gary were in the Hereford team for their Division 4 match at Scunthorpe. It was the first time a father and son had player together in the League since 1951. Gary scored his first ever League goal in the 3-3 draw while former European Cup winner, Ian, turned out in just one more League match before retiring from playing.

When Queen of the South made a substitution in the 87th minute, it wasn't just any normal change.

Lewis (L) and Willie (R) Gibson made history at the weekend (Credit: QOSFC.com)

Instead it led to a Scottish senior football first, as a father and son ended up playing for the  same team on the same pitch.Willie Gibson, player-manager for the Palmerston Park club, had subbed himself on in the second half of their League One match against FC Edinburgh. And with three minutes to go and the Doonhamers cruising 4-0, Gibson ordered for his son, Lewis, also a winger, to be brought on for the final few moments.